Curve was recently deployed on Celo. Following this deployment, the Celo community is proposing to add the agEUR / cEUR pool on Celo to the gauge controller so users can assign gauge weights and receive CRV incentives.
Mento protocol is a platform for using on-chain governance mechanisms to propose and launch governance approved stable assets. Today the family of Mento assets consists of cUSD, cEUR and cREAL on the Celo blockchain.
Starting from June 20, 2022 all Mento stable assets (cUSD, cEUR, cREAL) are fully backed by USDC and DAI in the Reserve (CGP-62).
cUSD (bridged via Portal) is already part of cUSD/FRAXBP pool on the Ethereum mainnet.
Angle is a decentralized stablecoin protocol issuing agEUR. agEUR has recently been made available on Celo through the Angle Bridge system that relies on LayerZero message passing solution and Angle security framework.
- About Mento:
Reserve stats: https://reserve.mento.org
Issuance & Redemption Mechanism: The Celo Reserve FAQs. What it is & how it works | by Markus Franke | The Celo Blog
Stability Protocol whitepaper: https://celo.org/papers/stability
Source code: Celo · GitHub
- About Angle:
Github Page Angle · GitHub
Discord: Angle Protocol
Audits: Audits - Angle Docs
Mento stable assets are backed by an on-chain Reserve. As mentioned in the summary, outstanding supply of Mento assets is fully backed by USDC and DAI. As of this writing, The Reserve is overcollateralized by 218% and consists of over $149M in holdings made up by 36M DAI, 31M USDC, 283 BTC, 4K ETH, 130M CELO, and 83K cMCO2, against an outstanding supply of $66M in stable assets.
As part of their research, the Mento team has simulated various market conditions (summary article), including bear market conditions. And while simulations can never capture all the complexities of the real world, analyses showed stability through a wide range of adversarial conditions and informed crucial design choices, such as diversifying the reserve by including low-volatility assets.
When the price of cEUR is below €1, an arbitrager can burn 1 cEUR and receive €1 worth of CELO from the reserve. When the price of cEUR is above €1, the arbitrager can mint 1 cEUR by depositing €1 worth of CELO to the Reserve. The Reserve is then periodically rebalanced to maintain the target allocation as per Celo governance.
CELO is held in the Reserve smart contract. The Reserve ensures that non-CELO reserve assets are held safely through the use of approved, qualified and licensed custodians, currently Anchorage (https://web.anchorage.com/anchorage-celo/) and Hex Trust (https://hextrust.com/), which do not operate in countries that are blacklisted by the Financial Action Task Force (FATF) or subject to any sanctions prohibitions. Custodians are required to make publicly available the assets they hold on behalf of the Reserve to ensure that Celo stakeholders and the broader Celo community have full transparency with respect to reserve assets.
Celo with Custodian
Anchorage holdings report (https://web.anchorage.com/anchorage-celo/)
Angle is a decentralized stablecoin protocol designed to be both over-collateralized and capital-efficient. The protocol has launched agEUR, a Euro stablecoin, which has become the biggest decentralized Euro stablecoin. The TVL in the Angle Protocol is $46m with $31m agEUR in circulation, as of this writing.
There are different mechanisms (also called modules) by which agEUR can be issued all having in common that agEUR must be released on the market in an over-collateralized way.
In the Core module of the protocol, agEUR can be minted from USDC, DAI and FRAX at oracle value. The protocol insures itself against the $/€ change risk by issuing perpetual futures and by relying on the deposits of another type of agent incentivized by the strategies built by the protocol and by transaction fees. agEUR issued from this means represent the biggest share of the agEUR in circulation, and they are currently over-collateralized at 200%
The protocol also has a borrowing module where agEUR can be borrowed against different assets (ETH, wBTC, wstETH) like on Maker. This module is deployed on different chains.
The protocol is also engaged in algorithmic market operations (also called direct deposit modules). It has for instance minted agEUR natively on Aave and on Euler. In these cases, agEUR enters in circulation when they are borrowed in an over-collateralized way on the corresponding protocol. Protocol also mints agEUR on the agEUR-EUROC Curve pool when this pool has more EUROC than agEUR (like what FRAX is doing)
agEUR has kept a super tight peg since its launch. It is involved in several other gauges on Curve as well (agEUR-EURs-EURt, agEUR-ibEUR, agEUR-EUROC-cEUR, agEUR-EUROC) which have historically yielded a pretty important volume. In the past, it has also helped other Euro stablecoins (like EURs) maintain peg when the redemption mechanism failed to work well.
Protocol is available on different chains beyond Ethereum, but not on Celo yet. The agEUR version available on Celo is a bridged version (with LayerZero). Angle has built a security framework that makes sure that its exposure to a bridge hack is pretty limited. It includes global and hourly limits.
Following the deployment of Curve on Celo, the proposal to add a cUSD / FraxBP gauge on Ethereum, and the deployment of agEUR on Celo, we hope to incentivize an agEUR / cEUR pool on Celo to further integrate the Celo protocol with the wider Curve ecosystem. A gauge will allow the Celo ecosystem to begin incentivizing an agEUR / cEUR pool. This will also build on Celo’s recent partnership with Wormhole to bridge cEUR.
Adding a gauge on Curve will help to increase liquidity of agEUR and cEUR, and increase the Celo ecosystem’s efforts to help build real world use cases and unlock the potential of regenerative finance. Given Celo’s partnership with Wormhole, the Celo community would like to make it easier for DeFi and payments users on Celo and other chains to actively participate in the Celo ecosystem, engage and use dApps on Celo, move across chains using stablecoins, and earn rewards on Curve for cEUR.
As agEUR does not exist natively on Celo, a gauge will also help facilitate the stabilization efforts of agEUR on Celo using cEUR which can be arb-ed directly on the chain.
- Governance: Provide current information on the protocol’s governance structure. Provide links to any admin and/or multisig addresses, and describe the powers afforded to these addresses. If there are plans to change the governance system in the future, please explain.
Mento uses a formal on-chain governance mechanism to manage and upgrade the protocol such as for upgrading smart contracts, adding new stable assets, or modifying the Reserve’s target asset allocation. All changes must be voted on by CELO holders. A quorum threshold model is used to determine the number of votes needed for a proposal to pass.
More details can be found here:
Angle: Angle governance is explained in details in this page of our docs. The Angle protocol is controlled by veANGLE holders which have the power to vote on Angle Improvement proposals. Votes are implemented on-chain by a 4/6 multisig composed of the following signers: Pablo Veyrat, Guillaume Nervo, Picodes (all 3 from Angle Core Team) @SebVentures (from Maker), Julien Bouteloup and 0xMaki.
- Oracles: Does the protocol rely on external oracles? If so, provide details about the oracles and their implementation in the protocol.
The Mento Protocol relies on oracles that report CELO/EUR rates on the following exchanges:
More details regarding the oracles and issuance & redemption mechanism can be found here:
Angle: The protocol uses Chainlink oracles (and in some cases Uniswap TWAPs in parallel to these feeds to make sure oracles are non manipulable)
- Audits: Provide links to audit reports and any relevant details about security practices.
The Mento Protocol has been audited by OpenZeppelin, Certora, Teserakt, and Trailofbits.
The process of reserve trading has been internally and externally (NCC group) audited.
A stability analysis was performed by Gauntlet and Economic Analysis by Prysm Group.
- Centralization vectors: Is there any component of the protocol that has centralization vectors? E.g. if only 1 dev manages the project, that is a centralized vector. If price oracles need to be updated by a bot, that is a centralized vector. If liquidations are done by the protocol, that is also a centralization vector.
As a threshold matter, the Mento Protocol is a stable asset platform that runs on the Celo Layer-1 decentralized, permissionless blockchain.
- Portions of the Reserve are held in centralized custody via Anchorage and Hex Trust. There is a multisig that can access these funds. The identity of these individuals and the number of trustees and thresholds for the multisig are not disclosed for security reasons. However, as mentioned above, custodians are required to make publicly available information on the assets they hold on behalf of the Reserve to ensure that Celo stakeholders and the broader Celo community have full transparency with respect to reserve assets. The reserve assets can be viewed on-chain at all times at the addresses listed above.
- Almost all Oracles that the Mento issuance & redemption mechanism relies on are currently run through on-chain smart contracts only accessible to certain accounts maintained by cLabs, with the ability for additional access to be added through the protocol’s governance process.
As part of Oracles decentralization effort, one Oracle is run by Celo community members (link to the proposal). The plan is to have at least half of the Oracles to be run by the community members by end of the year. In the nearest future Mento will have an automated on-chain circuit breaker to limit trading via mento when prices shift more than a calculated threshold (link to the proposal). The Mento issuance & redemption mechanism has safeguards in place to ensure that the reserve is protected in the case of oracle failure. (Celo Stability Algorithm (Mento) | Celo Documentation)
- Presently, there is an absence in the general market of a reliable and market-tested cross-chain value transfer solution. As such, the ‘cross-chain’ rebalancing still requires assets (e.g. Celo) be transferred via multisig to a CEX, traded against other assets (e.g. BTC) and then transferred back to a reserve address. Although the reserve address may be on a different blockchain, the whole process is fully transparent because the movement of funds in and out occurs on-chain and allows for the calculation of the implicit exchange rate. The administrative action to accomplish this change is required due to the currently available market infrastructures and is not specific to Celo. Before a trading session is started, a review is completed to check whether the distance to target weights and current liquidity levels require running a session - if not, no trading occurs. If yes, assets are traded as described above. The whole process of reserve trading has been internally and externally (NCC group) audited.
Angle: The protocol runs on decentralized systems, it relies on competitive liquidations, and vote-based governance. There’s no single person or dev with admin controls over the protocol. And as disclosed in question 1., the treasury and some part of the protocol are secured by a multisig of doxxed team members.
- Market History: Has the asset observed severe volatility? In the case of stablecoins, has it depegged? In the case of an unpegged asset, have there been extreme price change events in the past? Provide specific information about the Curve pool: how long has it been active, TVL, historical volume?
According to CoinMarketCap, since 29 June 2021 and until 20, January 2023, on a closing basis, cEUR was within +/-1.50% of the peg, 95% of the time and within +/-2.50% 99.6% of the time. cEUR withstood the market pressure caused by the collapse of UST; the on-chain stability mechanism Mento protocol immediately responded to excess supply around May 11, and remains within the peg as of the date of this proposal. Deviations from the peg are observed in relatively illiquid venues where small transaction sizes have a disproportionate impact on the price.
Angle: agEUR has remained stable since its launch, despite adverse market conditions. agEUR has held Curve pools for several months, for most of which it has provided a considerable share of volume on Ethereum and Polygon. During the week of the UST crash, it even helped EURs keep its peg while there was some lag in the redemption process. Same happened with ibEUR. It kept its stability as well during the market turmoil of the last months.